Caputo’s Pizza
About
Pizza, Wraps, Italian
Location
Adress: 36-42 James St, Middletown, NY 10940
Phone: (845) 342-1222
Work Hours
Business info
- turned_in_notHealth Score90 out of 100
- list_altTakes ReservationsNo
- credit_cardAccepts Credit CardsYes
- accessibilityGood for KidsYes
- tvHas TVYes
Reviews
-
Eve M.
You gotta try the chicken parm! It's seriously so good. I get two meals out of it. Get the dinner. Comes with soup or salad and fresh made bread! Soups are really good too! They have daily specials. You can see them posted on either Facebook or instagram. You can pay with card if you have it delivered to your place.
Really good food. Definitely give it a try! -
Evelyn C.
We ordered a half meat lover's pie (half plain) to a restaurant. Delivered to our hotel. I was told a half hour. I really don't mind waiting for food, just tell me it's going to be a while. Food arrived an hour later.
I understand charging for the bleu cheese dressing my husband likes to dip his crust in, but since they were delivering to a hotel room, I would expect a bit of extra diligence to include the plates and parm as requested. Unfortunately we didn't realize that was missing until the guy was paid and gone, so I called the place and the person was rather rude. "Well they did send the bleu cheese" -- yeah, I know.
I simply requested that they at least reverse the charge on the extra cheese but they said they couldn't do that. Sigh and oh well.
The pizza itself was pretty good. I'd give it 3 stars. A bit greasy and quite salty. Still good for this NY style pizza lover, born and raised. Reasonably priced. I'd order again, just make extra sure I could actually eat in my hotel room!! -
King Y.
Excellent food! Great service. Nice people. Boars head meats. Beautiful fish tank in the dining area! Best pizza downtown by far!!!
-
Becca M.
Best pizza I've ever had. There was a lot of flavors and the crust was absolutely perfect. Fluffy and soft but not too thick that you can call it thick crust pizza. It's still thin but not cardboard like, like most other places. I'd definitely come back to the east coast just for this pizza. The service was also amazing. The guy serving us was apparently the owner and he was very attentive, polite, very nice overall.
-
Heather W.
Since I'm in @new York from North Caroliba, I just had to do as the New Yorkers do and order some Italian food. Delicious! I'm a little disappointed as it is super quiet in the restaurant as I wanted to hear some loud Italian banter back and forth. I had the stuffed shells and garlic knots that came with a really nice salad for $11, yes, $11.